Lighthouse Lodge B&B on Lake Shafer

The Lighthouse Lodge B&B on Lake Shafer is a lakefront bed and breakfast in Monticello, Indiana, anchored by a historical stone lighthouse built in the 1930s, shortly after Lake Shafer was formed by the construction of Norway Dam. Situated 90 minutes from both Chicago and Indianapolis, the property offers direct lake access with a sandy beach, a large sundeck, and sweeping water views that make it a distinctive backdrop for weddings, family reunions, and corporate retreats. The venue accommodates up to 150 guests for outdoor receptions across its lake-level grounds, including a spacious deck suited for tent installation. Seven deluxe suites and a collection of two-bedroom cottages and waterfront chalets sleep up to 60 overnight guests, each outfitted with fireplaces, kitchenettes, and private bathrooms. On-site catering is available with a full menu developed by the owners, including options for gluten-free, dairy-free, and other dietary needs. The property also features a recreation room, fire pits, and a pontoon boat for lake excursions.